Reactions, Comments, and Questions...

Post a reaction, a comment, or a question here.  You can also respond to another person's post for credit.

Acting in the Dark...

Despite receiving an Oscar for this performance, Pacino has been criticized for oversimplifying his role in this film, as well as “overacting”.  Evaluate his performance based on what you have seen this semester, as well as how you feel Lieutenant Colonel Frank Slade should act.  This should include how dialogue is delivered, as well as the physical mannerisms and quirks that Pacino adopts for the role.

Traumatic Adoption

The focal point for the entire narrative of this film is the relationship between Charlie Simms and Frank Slade.  Are these characters foils?  How do they need each other both physically and emotionally?  How would you characterize their relationship?  In other words, what type of relationship do they have?  How does that relationship change and evolve?  What are some turning points?  Use specific references to the film to support your responses.

Above All Things...

Although women would seem to be central to the progression of this film, we rarely see them, and when we do it is only for fleeting moments.  What is the role of women in this film?  How are they portrayed, and what function to they perform?  Are these ideas idealized or realistic?  Does it matter?